Quebec's Bill 10: The End of 'Subscription Traps' and Ticket Scalping (Dec 2025)

What This Means for You

If you have ever spent hours waiting on hold just to cancel a streaming service or been gouged by hidden fees when buying concert tickets, your life as a consumer is about to get significantly easier—especially if you live in Quebec. Even if you don't, the "ripple effect" of Bill 10, tabled this week, may likely force major companies to improve their practices nationwide.

The legislation, introduced by Quebec's Justice Minister in December 2025, targets two of the most frustrating modern consumer experiences: "subscription traps" and the "Wild West" of ticket resale.

The "One-Click" Cancellation Right

The Problem: You can sign up for a service online in 30 seconds, but cancelling requires a 20-minute phone call to a "retention specialist" who is trained to not let you leave. The Fix: Bill 10 mandates that if a contract can be entered into online, it must be cancellable online.

Your New Rights:

The Button: Merchants must provide a "readily identifiable and accessible" cancellation button. No hiding it in the footer of a sub-menu.
No Retention Gauntlet: The process should be simple. If you click cancel, it should cancel.
Free Trials: If you sign up for a free trial, the company must send you a clear notice 2-10 days before the trial ends, telling you exactly how much you will be charged and how to cancel.

Action Item:

Audit Your Subscriptions: Check your credit card statement for "zombie subscriptions" (gyms, streaming, meal kits) you gave up trying to cancel. Once this bill passes, meaningful cancellation will be a click away.
For Non-Quebec Residents: When dealing with national companies (e.g., telecom, major streaming services), try changing your billing address to a Quebec address if you are blocked from online cancellation. Often, their systems will unlock the "Quebec-only" cancellation features.

The Ticket Resale Revolution

The Problem: You try to buy tickets to a show, they vanish instantly, and reappear on a resale site for 4x the price with "service fees" added at the last second. The Fix: Bill 10 amends the Consumer Protection Act to strictly regulate the secondary market.

Key Changes for Ticket Buyers:

Total Transparency: Resale platforms (like StubHub, Vivid Seats) must clearly disclose that you are buying a resale ticket and what the original price was.
Price Caps: Resale prices generally cannot exceed the original price authorized by the producer.
No "Transfer Fees": Charging a fee just to email a ticket to a friend or buyer is now explicitly banned.
Refunds for Scams: If a resale ticket turns out to be fake or is cancelled, the platform is liable.

What to Watch For:

"All-In" Pricing: The price you see on the search page must be the price you pay. No surprise "processing fees" at checkout.
Verified Sellers: Platforms must verify the identity of the reseller, reducing the chance of buying a ghost ticket.

The "Anti-Gag" Clause

Have you ever been afraid to leave a bad review because a company threatened to sue you or fine you?

New Right: Bill 10 prohibits any contract clause that prevents you from making a negative review or complaint.
Why It Matters: This empowers you to share honest feedback about bad contractors, faulty products, or poor service without legal intimidation.

The "Brussels Effect" (Why This Matters Outside Quebec)

Quebec often acts as Canada's "consumer protection laboratory." Because it is operationally expensive for companies like Netflix, Spotify, or Ticketmaster to build a separate website just for Quebec, they often apply the strictest standard to the entire country.

Prediction: Expect to see "Cancel Subscription" buttons appearing more prominently for all Canadian users in 2026 as companies update their UI to comply with Bill 10.

The News: What Happened

On December 2, 2025, Quebec's Minister of Justice, Simon Jolin-Barrette, tabled Bill 10: An Act to protect consumers against abusive practices in ticket reselling and online subscription renewal.

According to CBC News, the bill is a direct response to rising consumer complaints about the difficulty of unsubscribing from digital services and the opacity of the ticket resale market.

Key provisions cited in the legislation:

Cancellation: Amends the Consumer Protection Act to require that online contracts be cancellable online.
Decoupling: Prohibits the sale of a product contingent on the purchase of another (tied selling) in more contexts.
Ticket Resale: According to legal analysis by BLG, the bill imposes strict transparency requirements on resale platforms, mandating the disclosure of the original ticket price and prohibiting resale above that price unless authorized by the producer.

Langlois Lawyers notes that the bill also introduces stricter penalties for non-compliance, aiming to give the Office de la protection du consommateur (OPC) more teeth to enforce these digital rights.

Analysis: Why This Matters

This bill represents a modernization of consumer law for the "Ownerless Economy." As we move from buying things (DVDs) to renting access (Netflix), the power dynamic has shifted heavily to corporations who control the "off switch."

The "Dark Pattern" Crackdown

This legislation creates a legal definition for what UX designers call "Dark Patterns"—user interfaces designed to trick or trap users. By legislating "accessibility" of the cancellation button, Quebec is saying that User Experience (UX) is now a legal matter.

If a company makes you click 5 times to cancel, they aren't just annoying; they are arguably breaking the law.

The Ticketmaster War

This is part of a global backlash against the ticket monopoly and scalping ecosystem. By attacking the profitability of scalping (capping resale prices and banning transfer fees), Quebec is trying to de-incentivize the "bot armies" that scoop up tickets in milliseconds.

Challenge: Enforcing this against offshore resale sites will be difficult. The government will likely rely on blocking payments or fining the local credit card processors who facilitate these transactions.

Impact on Small Business

While aimed at giants, this affects any small business with a "Subscribe & Save" model. Local gyms, subscription box services, and SaaS companies in Quebec will need to audit their cancellation flows immediately. The days of "email us to cancel" are over.

Your Action Plan

Immediate (This Month):

List Your Subscriptions: Go through your bank statements for the last 12 months. Identify every recurring charge.
Test the "Cancel" Flows: Try to find the cancellation page for your services. If it's hard, file a complaint with the Office de la protection du consommateur (OPC).

When The Bill Passes (Expected Early 2026):

Use the Button: Cancel those borderline subscriptions you've been keeping just because it was a hassle to call.
Check Ticket Prices: When buying resale tickets, look for the mandatory "Original Price" disclosure. If it's missing, the platform is non-compliant.

For Business Owners:

Update Your UI: If you sell subscriptions, build your "Unsubscribe" flow now. Ensure it requires the same number of steps (or fewer) than the sign-up flow.
Rewrite Contracts: Remove any "non-disparagement" (anti-review) clauses from your terms of service.

Other Perspectives

The Industry View

Tech companies often argue that "friction" in cancellation is necessary to prevent accidental cancellations or to offer customers better deals (retention offers). They may argue that Bill 10 restricts their ability to "win back" customers. ADISQ (representing Quebec's music industry) has largely welcomed the ticket resale provisions, seeing them as a way to ensure fans can afford shows and artists get paid, rather than scalpers.

The Resellers' View

Ticket brokers argue that price caps drive the market underground (e.g., Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist) where there is zero consumer protection or fraud recourse. They argue that regulated platforms with higher prices are safer than unregulated black markets.

The "Freedom of Contract" Critique

Some legal scholars note that banning "non-disparagement" clauses interferes with private contracts. However, the prevailing view in consumer law (shared by the Competition Bureau) is that these clauses distort the market by hiding negative information from other consumers.

Corrections Policy

We strive for accuracy. If you find an error in this analysis, please email us at [email protected]. We will promptly investigate and correct any factual inaccuracies.

Updates: