Skip to main content
News Analysis

9% of Toronto Mortgage Holders May Be Unable to Refinance in 2027: What the Bank of Canada Warning Means for Your Renewal, Your Equity, and Your Plan B

The Bank of Canada's 2026 Financial Stability Report flags a 'death spiral' risk for highly-indebted Toronto homeowners renewing in 2027. Here's the exact playbook: how to renew without requalifying, when to call your lender, what payment shock to model, and which numbers actually matter.

By Refdesk Team

9% of Toronto Mortgage Holders May Be Unable to Refinance in 2027: What the Bank of Canada Warning Means for Your Renewal, Your Equity, and Your Plan B

What This Means for You

If you bought a home in 2022 or 2023, took a five-year fixed mortgage, and now hear the Bank of Canada warning that 9% of Toronto borrowers in your cohort won't be able to refinance at renewal in 2027 — your first reaction is probably either panic or denial. Neither is useful. The reality is that the data behind the warning is precise, the at-risk group is specific, and you can determine in about 15 minutes whether you're in it. More importantly, even if you are, there is a well-established path to renew without requalifying that costs you nothing and that almost every borrower has access to. The danger is not the renewal itself. The danger is making the wrong move in the months before the renewal — particularly missing payments, taking on new credit, or trying to switch lenders for a marginally better rate when you don't qualify. Here is the practical playbook, organised by your specific situation.

If You Took a 2022–2023 Five-Year Fixed Mortgage and Renew in 2027

You are the cohort the Bank of Canada is talking about. According to the Bank of Canada's 2026 Financial Stability Report, about 12% of all outstanding Canadian mortgages will renew in the next 12 months with an expected payment increase of roughly 15% on average. For Toronto-area borrowers in this cohort, the report estimates 9% would be unable to refinance at current home prices — rising to 12% if prices fall another 10%.

Immediate action this week:

  • Pull your current mortgage statement and write down four numbers: your current rate, your current monthly payment, your remaining principal, and your renewal date. Without these, every conversation that follows is guesswork.
  • Run a renewal estimate at three rate scenarios. Use the Government of Canada mortgage calculator at 4.5%, 5.0%, and 5.5% for a five-year fixed. For most pandemic-era borrowers locked in at sub-2.5%, the difference is a payment increase of 30–50%. The Bank's 15% average masks a wide distribution — your number may be higher.
  • Check your home's current estimated value using two independent sources. HouseSigma and a comparable-sales pull from the TRREB Market Watch report will give you a range. The Bank of Canada notes that Greater Toronto home prices have fallen approximately 5% over the past 12 months and 20% from the 2022 peak. If your purchase price is the only number you know, you're flying blind.

What to prepare:

  • Your "renewal with current lender" letter. According to mortgage broker Ron Butler, quoted by CP24, borrowers who renew with their current lender — without requesting additional funds or switching products — do not require requalification, an appraisal, or income verification, as long as payments are current. This is the single most important protection most homeowners do not know they have. Your lender is required to offer you renewal terms; you are not required to pass the federal mortgage stress test if you simply accept them.
  • A spreadsheet of your monthly cash flow at the renewed payment level. Run a 12-month budget at the new payment minus the old payment. If the gap is larger than 10% of your take-home pay, you need to start adjusting now — not in 2027.

Real cost calculation: A Toronto household with a CA$650,000 mortgage at 2.39% (a common 2022 pandemic rate) on a 25-year amortization currently pays approximately CA$2,876/month. Renewing in 2027 at 4.99% with 22 years remaining brings the monthly payment to approximately CA$3,946 — an increase of CA$1,070/month, or CA$12,840 per year. This is the payment shock the Financial Stability Report is modelling. If your household income hasn't grown by at least CA$15,000 (pre-tax) since 2022 to absorb it, you are in the vulnerable cohort.

If You're a Toronto Pre-Construction Condo Buyer Closing in 2026 or 2027

This is the most acute situation in the country right now. According to the Bank of Canada's report, "some buyers have struggled to close on pre-construction purchases because price declines have made it harder to secure financing." If you bought a pre-con unit in 2021 or 2022 at a price that is now well above the appraised market value, your lender will only finance the lower of the two — leaving you to bridge the gap in cash or walk away from your deposit.

Immediate action:

  • Get an early appraisal estimate now. Don't wait until 30 days before closing. Most condo brokerages will run a comparative market analysis for free.
  • Talk to a mortgage broker, not just your bank. B-lender (alternative lender) financing and second mortgages are expensive but may be the difference between closing and forfeiting a six-figure deposit.
  • Consider an assignment sale before closing. If the math doesn't work, selling your purchase contract to another buyer — even at a loss on your deposit — may be cheaper than closing into negative equity.

If You're a Homeowner With Significant Equity (Pre-2020 Purchase)

You are not the cohort the Bank of Canada is warning about. Your loan-to-value ratio is likely well under 70%, your equity buffer is substantial, and your renewal — even at a higher rate — is mechanical.

What to do: Use the spread between the posted rate and your discounted rate to negotiate aggressively at renewal. Lenders' retention budgets are tight in a high-arrears environment, and they will compete for low-risk customers. Get at least two competing rate quotes 120 days before renewal. The 0.20–0.40% spread is worth thousands over a five-year term.

For All Canadian Homeowners

The Bank of Canada's data shows that mortgage accounts more than 60 days in arrears among high-loan-to-income Toronto borrowers reached 1.33% in March 2026, up from 0.78% a year earlier. The 2018–2019 average was 0.1%. Arrears are concentrated, not broad — but they are climbing. If you have any reason to believe you might miss a payment in the next 12 months, the time to call your lender is before you miss it, not after. Lenders offer payment deferrals, skip-a-payment options, and temporary interest-only periods to performing borrowers far more readily than to delinquent ones.

The News: What Happened

According to CP24, the Bank of Canada's 2026 Financial Stability Report, released in late May 2026, estimates that approximately 4% of Canadian borrowers renewing a mortgage in 2027 would be unable to refinance at current home prices, with that figure rising to roughly 9% in the Greater Toronto Area. If home prices fall another 10%, those figures would climb to 7% nationally and 12% in Toronto.

As reported by Canadian Mortgage Trends, the at-risk population is concentrated among borrowers with high loan-to-income ratios who took out mortgages in 2022 and 2023, when both rates were low and Toronto prices were near their peak. The Bank of Canada notes that this cohort represents only 2% of outstanding mortgage balances nationally, but accounts for a disproportionate share of vulnerability.

The Bank of Canada report states that "households, businesses and banks have remained resilient" but that "vulnerabilities are building in some parts of the system." Approximately 12% of all outstanding Canadian mortgages — primarily five-year fixed mortgages originated during the pandemic — will renew in the next 12 months, with average payment increases of roughly 15%. An additional 14% of mortgages are variable-payment or shorter-term fixed mortgages that face renewal without significant anticipated payment changes.

Greater Toronto Area mortgage broker Ron Butler told CP24 that for borrowers who cannot refinance, "it's a death spiral for the people who are affected by it" — meaning they lose the ability to access home equity, switch lenders for a better rate, or restructure their amortization. Victor Tran of Rates.ca advised that borrowers in this position can renew with their current lender without requalification, an appraisal, or income verification, as long as they are not requesting additional funds. Toronto-area mortgage arrears on accounts more than 60 days past due reached 1.33% in March 2026 among high-loan-to-income borrowers, up from 0.78% a year earlier.

Analysis: Why This Matters

Based on our analysis of the Financial Stability Report, the headline "9% of Toronto borrowers can't refinance" understates a more important nuance: those borrowers can almost always still renew, just not on the terms they want. The federal mortgage stress test, which requires borrowers to qualify at the contract rate plus 2% or 5.25% (whichever is higher), applies when you switch lenders or refinance for additional funds. It does not apply when you simply accept your existing lender's renewal offer. This means the operational risk for most affected borrowers is not foreclosure — it is being trapped with their current lender at whatever rate that lender offers.

This trapping effect is the real cost. A borrower who cannot shop the market loses the negotiating leverage that typically saves 0.20–0.50% on a renewal rate, which on a $650,000 mortgage is roughly $1,300–$3,250 per year. Multiply that across the cohort and the household sector quietly loses billions in annual cash flow to lender pricing power that competition would otherwise discipline. This is a slow-burn drag on consumer spending, not a 2008-style cliff.

Historical Context

The closest analogue to the current situation is the 2018–2019 stress-test rollout, which similarly trapped a smaller cohort of borrowers with their existing lenders. That episode did not produce a wave of defaults — it produced a noticeable but contained reduction in refinance activity and a measurable widening of renewal spreads. The 2027 wave will be larger because the pandemic-era cohort is larger, and because home prices have fallen since origination rather than risen.

What Happens Next

Watch three indicators over the next 18 months. First, the November 2026 Financial Stability Report update — if Toronto arrears continue to climb past 1.5%, the Bank may flag systemic concerns. Second, OSFI's quarterly residential mortgage data, which will show the first wave of pandemic-cohort renewals starting in the third quarter of 2026. Third, lender retention-pricing behaviour: if the big six banks widen renewal spreads materially for trapped borrowers, expect a regulatory response by mid-2027.

Your Action Plan

Immediate (This Week):

  • Pull your mortgage statement and write down rate, payment, principal, and renewal date
  • Run a renewal payment estimate at 4.5%, 5.0%, and 5.5% using the federal mortgage calculator
  • Estimate your home's current value using HouseSigma or a TRREB comparables pull
  • Confirm your renewal date is at least 120 days away — if closer, accelerate the planning

Short-Term (This Month):

  • Build a 12-month budget at the renewed payment level
  • If you're in the at-risk cohort, request a renewal-options conversation with your current lender's mortgage specialist (no commitment required)
  • If you have equity and good credit, get two competing rate quotes from a broker
  • Cancel any pending applications for new credit cards or auto loans within 90 days of renewal

Long-Term (This Year):

  • At 120 days before renewal, request your current lender's renewal offer in writing
  • Compare against at least one external quote (broker or competing bank)
  • If accepting the renewal offer, lock the rate as early as your lender allows
  • Set up a monthly cash-flow check-in to confirm the new payment is absorbed without missing other obligations

Other Perspectives

Bank of Canada View:

According to the Financial Stability Report, the central bank's overall assessment is that "households, businesses and banks have remained resilient" through challenging conditions, with vulnerabilities concentrated in specific cohorts rather than systemic. The Bank emphasises that most borrowers facing renewal in 2025 and the first half of 2026 have absorbed payment increases.

Mortgage Industry View:

Ron Butler, a Greater Toronto Area mortgage broker, told CP24 that for borrowers who cannot refinance, "it's a death spiral." Victor Tran of Rates.ca emphasised that renewing with the current lender protects most borrowers from the worst outcomes.

Federal Regulator View:

The Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions has maintained its stress-test framework, with the Minimum Qualifying Rate currently set at the contract rate plus 2%. OSFI has signalled it will monitor renewal data closely but has not announced relief measures for the 2027 cohort.

Affected Homeowners' View:

Borrowers in the 2022–2023 cohort have raised concerns about being unable to access home equity for renovations, debt consolidation, or major expenses despite making payments on time. Community organisations and consumer advocates have called for a more flexible regulatory approach for performing borrowers whose only "failure" is a market price decline they did not cause.

Note: Including multiple perspectives doesn't imply all views are equally valid, but ensures readers can make informed judgments.

Corrections Policy

We strive for accuracy. If you find an error in this analysis, please email us at [email protected]. We will promptly investigate and correct any factual inaccuracies.

Updates:

  • No corrections to date (as of 2026-06-09)

Sources